For many buyers exploring York County, the draw of waterfront living is hard to resist. Two communities — Tega Cayand Lake Wylie — consistently top the list for those dreaming of life on or near the water. Both offer lake access, recreation, and proximity to Charlotte, but they deliver very different lifestyles.

Here’s how they compare so you can decide which waterfront community is the better fit.

1. Location and Access

Tega Cay sits on a peninsula extending into Lake Wylie, giving residents quick access to both Fort Mill and I-77. It’s just 30 minutes from Uptown Charlotte, making it ideal for commuters who want lake living without giving up city convenience.

Lake Wylie (the town) is farther southwest, about 40–45 minutes from Charlotte. It’s a bit quieter and less developed, which appeals to those seeking a slower pace and more space.

Takeaway:

• 
  

  Choose Tega Cay for convenience and quick Charlotte access.

  
  


• 
  

  Choose Lake Wylie for privacy and a more relaxed setting.

  
  

2. Housing and Neighborhoods

Tega Cay offers established neighborhoods with mature trees, golf course views, and waterfront homes mixed throughout. The homes here tend to be on smaller lots but are part of well-maintained, walkable communities.

Lake Wylie features a mix of older cottages, newer custom homes, and luxury waterfront estates. Buyers have more options for larger lots, wooded views, and direct water access.

Takeaway:

• 
  

  Tega Cay: Tight-knit neighborhoods, golf course amenities, family-friendly vibe.

  
  


• 
  

  Lake Wylie: Variety of home styles, larger lots, and more privacy.

  
  

3. Lifestyle and Recreation

Both areas center life around the lake — boating, kayaking, and fishing are part of everyday living.

• 
  

  Tega Cay adds a community-oriented feel with walking trails, tennis, and the Tega Cay Golf Club. Events like the 4th of July celebration and summer concerts bring neighbors together.

  
  


• 
  

  Lake Wylie is about laid-back lake life — marinas, restaurants on the water, and plenty of space for outdoor recreation without the crowds.

  
  

Takeaway:

• 
  

  Tega Cay: Active, social, and community-driven.

  
  


• 
  

  Lake Wylie: Peaceful, spacious, and private.

  
  

4. Schools and Community

Both Tega Cay and Lake Wylie are served by highly rated school districts. Tega Cay falls within the Fort Mill School District, one of the top in South Carolina. Lake Wylie belongs to the Clover School District, which also receives strong ratings and continues to grow.

Takeaway: Both areas offer excellent schools — your choice comes down to district preference and commute needs.

5. Price and Property Taxes

Home prices in both areas vary based on water access, but overall, Tega Cay tends to be slightly higher due to proximity to Fort Mill and I-77. Lake Wylie offers more range, from entry-level waterfront properties to luxury estates. Property taxes are comparable across York County and remain lower than neighboring Mecklenburg County.

Conclusion

Choosing between Tega Cay and Lake Wylie depends on your lifestyle priorities.

• 
  

  Tega Cay fits buyers looking for a connected, active community close to Charlotte.

  
  


• 
  

  Lake Wylie appeals to those who want more space, privacy, and a slower pace.

  
  

Either way, both deliver the best of York County’s waterfront living — scenic views, recreation, and the perfect blend of South Carolina charm and Charlotte convenience.